spiderbraids: (Default)
[personal profile] spiderbraids
This is the kind of junk that wouldn't be welcome at [community profile] winx_club. So, I'm posting it here instead.

Helia strings monster... but then lets monster free, 2x08: Tecna said it best when she said it was illogical. Totally agree. Especially since Flora could still have been attacked. (Also, it's a bit of a shame that Flora comes up with a great plan, and never gets to put it in action. Flora hardly gets any chances to shine as it is!)

Flora misses opportunities to hang with Helia, 2x13, and again in 2x22: Because it dragged out an already questionable storyline even further. Plus at the end of 2x22, if she did know that Helia was asking her out (or that she has to tell him how she feels someday), why doesn't she get the message and take the opportunity?

Diaspro never rants about Bloom, 2x14: Two things everyone was looking forward to when they learned of Diaspro's return: Diaspro having a convo with the couple, and/or Diaspro ranting about the couple. The first one doesn't happen in either version, and I know 4K bashing is not tolerated around [community profile] winx_club, but I don't think their choice to dub away the second when it does happen was such a good idea. You KNOW people will remember the incident, and the recap even shows it. So why not just let Diaspro have her rant?

Tune is not there to comment about Musa saying "Chillax", 2x16: Actually, more like the fact that the much-ballyhooed "Tune tries to get used to Musa's slang" angle of their bonding was hardly played on at all. Just Tune complaining that FG was bugging Musa (2x07) and nothing else.

Musa accuses random witch of attacking her last year, 2x17: The saddest part isn't that it makes Musa look (the Magix version of) racist, but rather that the scene would actually have worked MUCH better (remember, continuity = good) if the witches that were attacking her were actually there. Heck, Musa could have been yelling at Lucy and it would have worked better. Even if the writers were trying to make Musa look racist (if so, honestly, what were they thinking?), they completely dropped that thread in the next episode, raising the question, "What was the point?"

The plot conveniently forgets the homesickness spell incident, 2x20: Where I live, New!Pally does briefly address the problem, but then he just decides that since LD will be focusing on the Winx, it might be safe for Livy to return to the village, and tells him to take a low profile. Dumb. Over there, it doesn't get addressed at all. Lame. (Funny that it's the forgetful pixie who gets involved in this...)

The whole bit where the Winx were grounded, 2x24: First Flora takes on Icy's Ice Crusher. Haven't two years of attacks like these taught them that the first weapon you use against Icy is either Bloom or Stella? Next, instead of finishing them off and ensuring their death as they probably normally would, the Trix fly off and assume that the Crusher will finish them off for them. Didn't Tecna say something about making assumptions being a ridiculously illogical leap in reason? Lastly, when Stella does use her powers, she not only uses it from inside the ship instead of above the Crusher, thus endangering them, but also steps on a perfectly logical plan Tecna and Timmy were coming up with, which we don't even get to find out what it was. This is Winx Club, not Keystone Kops.

Date: 2006-09-22 06:00 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] mg-winxclub.livejournal.com
You said it right in your first sentence, junk. How can you post this junk and still call yourself a fan? The lowlight of season 2 is you complaining about it all the time, as much as you could, and as many times as you could everywhere! Read your thread above again and ask youself this simple question:

Will this help make someone a fan of Winx Club?

Since the answer is no, go talk about something else and leave Winx Club alone. You ask about ethics and why you were banned, I point you once again to your thread above, posting this junk is not in good taste for someone claiming to be a fan of Winx Club. Why is it so hard for you to understand this???

Date: 2006-09-23 09:37 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] spiderbraids.livejournal.com
What I meant was that even if I was still a member of [community profile] winx_club, I probably would have posted this here anyways, since anything that paints WC in a bad light is not accepted over there.

Just because I'm a fan of Winx doesn't mean I have to like everything about it, right?

Date: 2006-09-23 02:57 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] mg-winxclub.livejournal.com
I didn't say you have to like everything. Gosh, you're so hopeless. You're always negative. How often to you even post "positive" threads about Winx Club? Almost never and that's sad. Even your track record on ToonZone.net backs this up too.

Date: 2006-09-23 06:54 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] tanz-fanatika.livejournal.com
But if you were a real fan, you wouldn't think about this stuff enough to make an entire post about it. You'd talk about it during episode discussion and then let it go.

You don't see me or anyone else in [community profile] winx_club making posts like this. That's because we're the real fans.

Date: 2006-09-30 06:36 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ddrfan.livejournal.com
0_______________0 Please stop....you are dragging yourself down...





GET SOME HELP!

July 2025

S M T W T F S
  12345
67 89101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 21st, 2025 08:43 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios